Southern Appalachian Digital Collections

Western Carolina University (20) View all

Cataloochee tract 292: J. L. C. Messer

items 2 of 45 items
  • record image
Item
?

Item’s are ‘child’ level descriptions to ‘parent’ objects, (e.g. one page of a whole book).

  • CATALOOCHEE HISTORIC DISTRICT: CULTURAL LANDSCAPE REPORT GREAT SMOKY MOUNTAINS NATIONAL PARK January 2000 Dianne L. Flaugh Historical Landscape Architect Cultural Resources Resource Management Great Smoky Mountains National Park National Park Service I I I I I I I I I I I • CHAPTER 4: INDIVIDUAL TRACTS E. M. Messer Tract (293) J. L. C. Messer Tract (292) Location 157 These two tracts are located along Snake Branch in Caldwell Fork. Tract 292 is a 50.26- acre parcel, beginning at the juncture of Snake Branch with Caldwell Fork and extending eastward along Snake Branch. Tract 293 is a 73.5-acre parcel that abuts the east bound­ary of tract 292. History This land was first bonded to G. N. Penland in 187 4, from the Love holdings. Beginning in 1892, the property went passed various hands until Steve and Mary Woody bonded the land to E. M. Messer in 1895. In 1897, the land was transferred to Will Messer (son ofEiijah) but returned to Elijah's name the following year. In 1918, Elijah M. Messer transferred tract 292 to J. L. C. Messer (Carson) in return for home and home comforts. Elijah Messer also transferred adjoining tracts of land to his son George (tract 2~4) and to Nicey M. Parton (tract 295). The NCPC purchased all of these tracts in 1930. Little is known of the early history of these tracts. None of the early owners of the property appear on any of the agricultural census records. It is possible that they rented the property to others during their ownership. Elijah Messer and his frrst wife Christina M. arrived in Cataloochee just after the Civil War, settling frrst on Messer Branch and later moving to Caldwell Fork (year unknown).' They frrst appear on the census records ofCataloochee in 1880, along with five chil­dren. 2 He listed his occupation as a farmer but was known as an expert axman, comerman and stonemason. He also had the reputation as one ofthe best fiddle players in the region.3 It is unknown ifhe was living in Caldwell Fork in 1880, but agriculture census records show that he farmed a fifty acre tract. This land included seventeen acres of cleared land. Eight acres was devoted to com and three to wheat. Livestock included working animals, cattle, sheep, and swine, but the majority of his stock was swine. His swineherd at that time numbered nineteen hogs. By 1900, the Elijah Messer household in Caldwell Fork included his second wife Elizabeth; sons John L. and George M.; and sister Nancy [Nicey]. By this time Will Messer and Rachel Cook had already established their own household in Little Cata­loochee. Vegetation NCPC records for tract 292 indicate that it consisted of thirty acres of cleared land and twenty acres of woodland. Tract 293 consisted of thirty-five acres of cleared land and thirty-eight and one-half acres of woodland. Details about the types of crops grown by the Messers, and the number of acres devoted to differing crops are unknown. A photo­graph (ca. 193 7) of the Carson Messer house shows cleared land southwest of the house. '-- 158 C ULTIJRAL L ANDSCAPE REPORT: C ATALOOCHEE HISTORIC DISTRICT Circulation From the road along Caldwell Fork Creek, a road branched off to run eastward along Snake Branch. This route provided access to these tracts and those further up Snake Branch. On tract 293, a trail extended northward to cross Snake Ridge. Structures, Furnishings, and Objects NCPC records for tract 292 indicate that it included a gristmill, four-room log house, six-stall barn, two shops and a springhouse. Later building survey notes provide addi­tional information and noted that the site had once also included tub mill that had been removed. The overshot mill was a frame building weatherboarded with rived hemlock (figure 60). All of the mill equipment had already been removed from the structure before the NCPC purchased the property. Figure 60. Carson Messer Mill, ca. 1930. Wilburn Photo Album, GRSM Archives. The log house stood one and one-half stories high and was constructed of hemlock, poplar, and chestnut logs. The dovetailed logs were chinked with split rails outside and rived boards inside. The house included a front porch and frame room addition (figure 61). One former resident of Caldwell Fork remembers the Carson Messer house for it's running water. The house was built against a bank out of which a two-inch stream of water flowed into the house. 4 The barn measured 61' by 33' in size. Its pens were nine feet high with notched comers. The crib had dovetailed comers. The barn was constructed of poplar and pine logs and its roof of split shingles supported by silver bell pole. Other outbuildings included a smokehouse and springhouse. The log smokehouse stood seven logs high and measured 10' by 12' in size. The springhouse measured 6' by 8' , stood eight logs high, and had a four-foot overhang. This springhouse was well constructed of poplar and hemlock with dovetail comers, rived chinking on the inside, and weatherboarded as beveled siding. Troughs stood outside. The building survey also noted that the site included a sorghum furnace. I I I I I I I I I I I I~ I I I I I I I ' I I I • I ~ ~ CHAPTER 4: INDIVIDUAL TRACTS 159 Tract 293 included a two-room log house and three old sheds. Later building sutvey notes provide little additional information other than calling for the removal of a frame house, shed, and pigpen. 5 Figure 61 . Carson Messer House, 1937. GRSM Archives. Existing Conditions The area of Messer tracts 293 and 294 is included within subzone Natural Environment­Type I, which emphasizes the natural environment. Both tracts have entirely reforested. Tulip poplar, white pine, and maple dominate the forest cover of formerly open agricul­turalland. The historic routes through these tracts are still evident and form the basis of Boogerman Trail. The Boogerman Trail is a popular loop trail in Cataloochee and is open only to foot traffic. Also found on the Messer tracts are road traces; one leading to a field area above a stone retaining wall, and another along the north bank of Snake Branch. This second trace road is possibly associated with the gristmill. None of the structures documented as part ofbuilding sutvey work are extant Traces of rail fencing are evident along Snake Branch along side the trace road. Photographs of the mill also depict rail fencing. Extensive stone retaining walls are found on both tracts. On the Carson Messer tract one 'L' shaped wall extends thirty-five feet along Boogerman trail and seventy feet northward. On the E. M. Messer tract a five-foot high retaining wall extends approximately one hundred feet along Boogerman trail. A break in this wall marks a road trace leading to the field area above this wall. A small cemetery known as the Carson Messer cemetery is found above this field area. It is surrounded with wire fence and includes at least two graves marked with uninscribed limestone grave markers . Analysis and Evaluation This site is associated with the Messer family and was the site of a large gristmill. Reforestation and the removal ofbuildings have impacted the site. However, the. reforested agricultural land remains evident, dominated by pioneer tree species. While no buildings remain standing, there are small scale landscape elements and remnants that 160 CUL11JRAL LANDSCAPE REPORT: CATALOOCHEE HlsTORIC DISTRICT illustrate the historic use of the site. These include structural elements such as walls, fences, and log remnants of the bam. A cemetery is also found here. Historic circulation patterns through the site remain evident. The mountainous setting and remaining land­scape elements attest to the difficult nature of subsistence farming in Cataloochee. NOTES 1 Elizabeth Powers and Mark Hannah. Cataloochee:Lost Settlement of the Smokies (Charleston, SC: Blazer Print, 1983), 51. 2 Children included three sons and two daughters: James, 13; William, 10; Sarah, 7; Chassie, 5; and George, 2. 3 Roy Carroll and Raymond H. Pulley, "Historic Structures Report: Jim Hannah Cabin, Will Messer Bam, and Dan Cook Cabin," (Appalachian State University, Department of History, 1976), 22. 4 Thad Sutton, Interview by Jacqueline Lott and author, Written notes, Waynesville, NC, 12 January 1998. 5 Charles Grossman, Grossman Notebooks, B-4, GRSM Archives. I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
Object
?

Object’s are ‘parent’ level descriptions to ‘children’ items, (e.g. a book with pages).